Friday, September 12, 2008

Thoughts On Post-Nicene Trinitarian Controversies

Christianity owes much to Athanasius.
His apologetic contributions towards a more holistic trinitarian theology; and his stand against Arianism, have spurned Christians onwards towards orthodox Christology for centuries.

On Incarnation of the Word was written prior to the emergence of Arian nontrinitarian dogmas concerning the Logos, and in many ways, foreshadows the creed written at the Council of Nicea in 325 A.D. The battle began in full force with Athanasius’ scathing response to Arius, detailed in his First Discourse Against the Arians, in which he writes of Arianism,

“…one heresy, and that the last, which has now risen as harbinger of the Antichrist”.


Out of all the known heresies, Athanasius considered the Arian heresy to be particularly insidious to fundamental dogmatic beliefs on the immutable nature of God. Arius, stipulated that though the Son was God, he was a created being (hence, there was a time when he 'was not'), while the entity of God the Father remained in His uncreated state.

As I was reading through Athanasius' First Discourse, the phrases “He is very God”, and “God from God” reminded me of the second verse of the Latin hymn Adeste Fideles (“O Come, All Ye Faithful”). Most likely, the text is probably derived from, or was influenced by, portions of the most famous creed in Christendom: the Nicene Creed. Alternatively, my more exotic theory is that some ancient author thought he would beat Arius at his own game by musically propagating his refutation of Arianism (visualize a 4th century “Billboard Top Ten” showdown).

After Athanasius, Post-Nicene church father Basil of Caesarea picked up the torch. Basil sought to clarify the divine paradox implied with the word hypostases, citing John 6:63:
“The Spirit gives life, the flesh counts for nothing. The words I have spoken to you are Spirit, and they are life”.
Most notably, Basil considered Christ’s perpetual existence as the Word Made Flesh of the utmost importance, differentiating between ousia (“substance” or “essence”) and hypostasis (“reality” or “person”) in the second figure of the Godhead.

The concept of an eternity outside of the realms of time and space often overwhelms my finite understanding. Once God's grace illuminates our understanding, our eyes are opened to the vista of His creation and His beauty as never before. When we are faced with the incomparable riches of the cross, we find ourselves at a loss for words.

What are we to do? How do we even begin to respond?

Look to Jesus.

"Listen to me, you who pursue righteousness,
you who seek the LORD:
look to the rock from which you were hewn,
and to the quarry from which you were dug." (Is. 51:1)

If the revelation of God the Father is a perfect and exact representation of His grace, then the full knowledge of the triune Godhead is continually revealed in His creature’s acceptance and yearning after the image of God. By the indwelling of the Spirit, His image can be found in those who take after Jesus' humble obedience (Phil. 2), denying themselves in order that they might gain Christ (Mark 8:34-37) so that He might be glorified.

In light of 1 Corinthians 8:6, the personal assurance the Incarnation holds comforts me in my human incapacity to know the Logos fully:
“yet for us there is but one God, the Father, from whom are all things and we exist for Him; and one Lord, Jesus Christ, by whom are all things, and we exist through Him”. ---1 Cor. 8:6

Because He is, I know that I have been created with a purpose: to exist for God the Father, “from whom are all things”; through the existence of Jesus Christ, “by whom are all things”. To say, as Arius did, that the Christ “by whom are all things” was a created being, is to say that there was a time when God the Father Himself did not exist fully!

Theology may not always work like clockwork. And yet, though the veil of unbelief has gradually been lifting over the years, I am still awed by the sheer absurdity of the Incarnation. In the words of Quoholeth,
“He has made everything beautiful in its time. He has also set eternity in the hearts of men; yet they cannot fathom what God has done from beginning to end.” (Ecc. 3:11)
What could have motivated the transcendent God to voluntarily tabernacle in hearts blackened by sin?

There are worlds of answers, but the reigning truth is found in God Himself.
If God’s own glory is the ultimate end of Creation, then God is manifestly glorified in revealing Himself to mankind at His discretion. Therefore, if God created mankind to further magnify His Name, then the transformative redemption of mankind, through the incarnation of Jesus Christ (Rom. 5:8), fulfills the Old Covenant law with the New (Jer. 31).

Furthermore, if the self-revelatory nature of the Word of God through the indwelling presence of Jesus Christ is a means of a further knowledge of God, then fulfillment of the knowledge of the Old Covenant law is demonstrated by mankind’s obedience, true worship, and servanthood, for His name’s sake (Is. 49:3). Gregory of Nyssa, in his Seventh Homily on the book of Ecclesiastes, described the conundrum of infinity with child-like simplicity:
“Our minds love to know only about God's transcendence of which they are persuaded because his nature differs from anything we know”.

---non nobis, Domine---


1 comment:

Jeremy said...

Do you think the Nicene Creed is exactly what the apostles and early church would have understood as Jesus' true identity? Or would you consider it an approximation, something that is sufficient for this time and place, but not a perfect description of who Jesus is? Would you ever be in favor of an updated Nicene Creed if you thought this update adhered to Scripture more closely?